Decisions - BC Forest Appeals Commission

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Jason Matthew Carmichael; Ian Robert Carmichael; Linda Joanne Carmichael v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa091a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 6, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-091(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Evelyn McIntyre; Frank McIntyre and Joy McIntyre v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for015a_016a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 28, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-015(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Cam McDonald and Tom Hallbauer v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for015a_016a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 28, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-016(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
McDonald Ranch and Lumber Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for014a_017a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 28, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-017(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Beau West Ranches Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for014a_017a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 28, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-014(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Richard Buck v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATION CONFIRMED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa014a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 27, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-014(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Robert Peebles v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEALS ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa015a_016a_017a_092a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 27, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-015(a)

2005-FA-016(a)

2005-FA-017(a)

2005-FA-092(a)

Act:

Forest Act
L & M Lumber Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party Sierra Club of Canada; Council of Forest Industries, Intervenors

Application for intervenor status

COMMISSION GRANTS APPLICANT’S APPLICATION

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005for001b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 25, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FOR-001(b)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Pope & Talbot Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party Council of Forest Industries, Applicant

Application for intervenor status

COMMISSION GRANTS APPLICANT’S APPLICATION

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005for004a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 5, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FOR-004(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Echa-Peh Forest Resources Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa034a_040a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 29, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-034(a)

2005-FA-035(a)

2005-FA-036(a)

2005-FA-037(a)

2005-FA-038(a)

2005-FA-039(a)

2005-FA-040(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Western Forest Products Limited v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

PANEL RESCINDS THE SANs UNDER APPEAL, REGIONAL APPRAISAL COORDINATOR TO REAPPRAISE THE STUMPAGE RATES

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa003c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 21, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-003(c)

Act:

Forest Act
James Darwin v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for012a_021a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 22, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-012(a)

2004-FOR-021(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
E.A. Strimbold Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS RESCINDED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa072a_073a_074a_075a_076a_077a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 6, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-072(a)

2005-FA-073(a)

2005-FA-074(a)

2005-FA-075(a)

2005-FA-076(a)

2005-FA-077(a)

Act:

Forest Act
L & M Lumber Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party Sierra Club of Canada, Applicant

Application for intervenor status

COMMISSION GRANTS APPLICANT’S APPLICATION

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005for001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 30, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FOR-001(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
David S. Burkholder Jr. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS RESCINDED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa033a_064a_065a_066a_067a_068a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 30, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-033(a)

2005-FA-064(a)

2005-FA-065(a)

2005-FA-066(a)

2005-FA-067(a)

2005-FA-068(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Single Tree Holdings Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS RESCINDED; REFERRED BACK WITH DIRECTIONS

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa041a_042a_043a_044a_045a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 30, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-041(a)

2005-FA-042(a)

2005-FA-043(a)

2005-FA-044(a)

2005-FA-045(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Dan Hamblin v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS RESCINDED; REFERRED BACK WITH DIRECTION

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa047a_049a_050a_051a_052a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 30, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-047(a)

2005-FA-049(a)

2005-FA-050(a)

2005-FA-051(a)

2005-FA-052(a)

Act:

Forest Act
James Douglas Brown-John; Deborah May Brown-John; Arrowhead Enterprises Ltd.; the Estate of David George Falconer v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa084a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 17, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-084(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Mike Whieldon; B & M Logging Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATION RESCINDED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for019a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 9, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-019(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Barrie Michael Redl doing business as Redl Ranch v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS RESCINDED; REFERRED BACK WITH DIRECTION

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa018a_019a_020a_021a_022a_23a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 9, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-018(a)

2005-FA-019(a)

2005-FA-020(a)

2005-FA-021(a)

2005-FA-022(a)

2005-FA-023(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Teal Jones Forest Ltd. and Teal Cedar Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa072-074a_080-083a_089a_2005fa031a_046a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 20, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-072(a)

2004-FA-073(a)

2004-FA-074(a)

2004-FA-080(a)

2004-FA-081(a)

2004-FA-082(a)

2004-FA-083(a)

2004-FA-089(a)

2005-FA-031(a)

2005-FA-046(a)

Act:

Forest Act
West Fraser Mills Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa032a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 29, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-032(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Jack Alexander Bellamy (Horning Forest Products and Services Ltd.) v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa075a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 22, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-075(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Weyerhaeuser Company Limited v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

DISTRICT MANAGER’S DETERMINATIONS ARE RESCINDED, APPEALS ARE ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for020a_025a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 20, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-020(a)

2004-FOR-025(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa062a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 15, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-062(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Weldwood of Canada Limited (now 100 Mile Lumber, a Division of West Fraser Mills Ltd.) v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa078a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 14, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-078(a)

Act:

Forest Act
James Edward Bradshaw v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS REFERRED BACK TO MINISTRY WITH DIRECTIONS

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa012a_013a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 13, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-012(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Raven Ranch Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

DETERMINATIONS REFERRED BACK TO MINISTRY WITH DIRECTIONS

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2005fa012a_013a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 13, 2005

Decision Number:
2005-FA-013(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Marilyn Abram v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for013a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 12, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-013(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Dave Tremblay v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

007, 008, 010 – DISMISSED; 009, 011 – ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for007a_008a_009a_010a_011a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 1, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-007(a)

2004-FOR-008(a)

2004-FOR-009(a)

2004-FOR-010(a)

2004-FOR-011(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Eric and Pam Meutzner v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa031a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 24, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-031(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Canadian Forest Products v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for022a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 17, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-022(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
West Fraser Mills Ltd. v. Ministry of Forests

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa041a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 14, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-041(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Louisiana-Pacific Canada Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Downie Timber Ltd., Graham’s Farms Ltd., Third Parties

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for006a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 22, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-006(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Doman-Western Lumber Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa048a_049a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
January 10, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-048(a)

2004-FA-049(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Tahtsa Timber Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa042a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
January 6, 2005

Decision Number:
2004-FA-042(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Western Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa043a_044a_045a_046a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 31, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-043(a)

2004-FA-044(a)

2004-FA-045(a)

2004-FA-046(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Esker Lake Forest Management Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa059a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 22, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-059(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa069a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 20, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-069(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Weyerhaeuser Company Limited v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEALS DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa035a_036a_037a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 17, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-035(a)

2004-FA-036(a)

2004-FA-037(a)

Act:

Forest Act
MJM Forestry Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa061a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 15, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-061(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Tackama Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa026a_027a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 9, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-027(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa026a_027a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 9, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-026(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Deverne and Charlene Durning v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa050a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 1, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-050(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Greg DuBois v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa068a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 1, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-068(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Western Forest Products Limited v. Government of British Columbia

Preliminary issue of jurisdiction

IN CONTEXT OF STUMPAGE DETERMINATIONS AT ISSUE, NO REVIEW IS REQUIRED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa003b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 29, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-003(b)

Act:

Forest Act
Galloway Lumber Company Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa052a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 25, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-052(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Stuart Lake Lumber Co. Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa055a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 22, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-055(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Williams James Hadden v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004fa060a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 22, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FA-060(a)

Act:

Forest Act
Weyerhaeuser Company Limited v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Consent order

DETERMINATION RESCINDED, PENALTY VARIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2004for004a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 10, 2004

Decision Number:
2004-FOR-004(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Acts